🥖
✓ verified
Country Club Bakery
Birthplace of the Pepperoni Roll
The source. In 1927, former coal miner Giuseppe 'Joseph' Argiro baked pepperoni inside soft white bread here so miners had a portable lunch — and the West Virginia pepperoni roll was born. They still pull fresh, warm rolls from the oven all day, every day, each packed with hand-cut pepperoni sticks. A Legends & Lore historical marker stands out front. Buy them by the bagful. Two eat for around $8.
📍 Fairmont, WV (1211 Country Club Rd) · ⏳ Daily · check hours
🍕
✓ verified
Colasessano's
World Famous Pizza & Pepperoni Buns
A Fairmont family institution since 1950 and the spot many locals say perfected the form. Colasessano's calls theirs pepperoni 'buns' — generously sized, stuffed with five to six pepperoni sticks, then topped with sauce, cheese and peppers. Get one with a pizza and two eat happily. Two eat for around $14.
📍 Fairmont, WV · ⏳ Check hours
🍝
✓ verified
Muriale's Italian Kitchen
Regional Italian Mainstay Since 1969
A north-central West Virginia favorite since 1969, Muriale's serves generous plates of pasta, veal and Italian-American classics in a big, welcoming room. A regional institution that still feeds two for a fair price. Two eat for around $18.
📍 Fairmont, WV · ⏳ Check hours
🍴
✓ verified
Mama Di Roma
Downtown Italian & NY-Style Pizza
A cheery downtown storefront café with a massive menu combining authentic Italian dishes, New York-style pizzas, salads (get the house dressing) and a giant pepperoni roll. Casual, friendly and great value. Two eat for around $16.
📍 Fairmont, WV (Downtown) · ⏳ Check hours
🥪
✓ verified
Uncle Ronnie's Sandwich Shop
Creative Subs & Hoagies
A newer downtown spot offering more than 20 creative subs, sandwiches and hoagies on rolls baked fresh that morning. Order the local-favorite 'Willy' — pepperoni, salami, capicola, lettuce, tomato, onion and cheese on a pillowy-yet-crusty roll. Two eat for around $12.
📍 Fairmont, WV (Downtown) · ⏳ Check hours
🥨
✓ verified
Abruzzino's Italian Bakery
Soft-Bread Pepperoni Rolls
A Marion County bakery credited as among the first to switch to a softer, sweeter bread for its pepperoni rolls — a gentler take than the firm Italian loaf of the originals. A fresh, cheap stop for the roll-curious. Two eat for around $8.
📍 Fairmont, WV area (Gypsy) · ⏳ Bakery · check hours
🍦
✓ verified
Dairy Creme Corner
Drive-In Ice Cream & Pepperoni Rolls
A classic Fairmont drive-in and Pepperoni Roll Trail stop — soft-serve cones, sandwiches and, of course, pepperoni rolls. The cheap, nostalgic move on a warm day. Two eat for around $10.
📍 Fairmont, WV · ⏳ Seasonal · check hours
🍲
✓ verified
The Dutchman's Daughter
European Homestyle Cooking
A quaint, European-style spot in nearby White Hall serving homestyle dinners, pastas, hoagies and desserts, with daily specials like meatloaf and chicken 'n' dumplings (and tasty salmon cakes). Comforting and well-priced. Two eat for around $16.
📍 White Hall, WV (near Fairmont) · ⏳ Check hours
🥩
✓ verified
Say-Boy Restaurant
Homestyle Diner Favorite
A longtime area favorite for homestyle comfort cooking and steaks in a retro, friendly room. The kind of unfussy, generous local spot two can fill up at without overspending. Two eat for around $18.
📍 Fairmont, WV · ⏳ Check hours
🧁
✓ verified
Apple Annie's
Bakery & Sweets
A local bakery beloved for fresh sweets and savory pepperoni rolls alike — a cheap, friendly stop to grab a roll and a treat to go. Two eat for around $10.
📍 Fairmont, WV · ⏳ Bakery · check hours
🍺
✓ verified
Meagher's Irish Pub
Downtown Irish Pub
A downtown Fairmont Irish pub for hearty pub fare, craft drafts and an easygoing night out — a change of pace from all the red sauce and pepperoni. Two eat for around $16.
📍 Fairmont, WV (Downtown) · ⏳ Check hours
🍔
✓ verified
Copper House Grill
Marion County Grill
A Marion County grill featured on the local pepperoni roll tour, plating casual American food and shareable bites in a relaxed setting. Two eat for around $16.
📍 Fairmont, WV area · ⏳ Check hours
💡 Pro tip: All deals are community-verified. We linked official menus only where we could confirm them (Country Club Bakery has one), so most spots here are map-only. Do the pilgrimage: an original at circa-1927 Country Club Bakery, then a sauced-and-cheesed "bun" at Colasessano's — two people can eat the birthplace of a West Virginia icon for well under $20. Grab the free Pepperoni Roll Trail passport from the Marion County CVB if you want to make a day of it. Hours and prices change, so check before a special trip. If something's expired, flag it on our main directory so we can update it.
These chain deals work anywhere in the country, including Fairmont.
🧀
✓ verified
Buffalo Wild Wings
Pick 6 — Meal for Two from $19.99
The Pick 6 lets two people build a shared meal — choose six items across wings, tenders, and sides — starting around $19.99. A reliable two-for-$20 play at any BWW. Dine-in or takeout; pricing varies slightly by market.
🌶️
✓ verified
Chili's
3 for Me — about $10.99/person
Each person picks a starter, full entrée, and non-alcoholic drink. Roughly $10.99/person — one of the best per-head values in casual dining.