🍕
✓ verified
Casa D'Amici
Two Pepperoni Rolls — $13.00 💡 Slices $3 Till Late
The late-night anchor of High Street, steps from the downtown campus — and the cult-favorite pepperoni roll is more stromboli than snack. Owner menu: the pepperoni roll is $6.50, so two are $13.00; slices are $3.00 (four for $12), and a small 14-inch Napolitan is $12.99 split between two. One correction to the address every aggregator copies: it's 419 High Street, not 485, with a second shop at 5003 Mid Atlantic Rd. Kitchen runs to 2:30am Thursday and 3:30am Friday–Saturday — exactly what you want after a Mountaineers game.
📍 419 High St + 5003 Mid Atlantic Rd · ⏳ Late: Thu to 2:30am, Fri–Sat to 3:30am
🥖
Mid Atlantic Market
Locals' #1 Pepperoni Rolls 💡 Call for Prices
When locals voted on the best pepperoni rolls in Greater Morgantown, this deli-bakery-cafe-and-market off I-68 came out on top. Grab a pack of minis or a party tray of the warm, pepperoni-stuffed West Virginia staple. Honesty requires a caveat: the menu on their own site is posted as photos with no prices, so we can't print a number — call (304) 777-4686 before a special trip. The hours, at least, are heroic: 5:30am to midnight, every day.
📍 7000 Mid Atlantic Dr (off I-68) · ⏳ Daily 5:30am–midnight
🥐
Chico's Bakery
Julia's Pepperoni Rolls 💡 Cases Online, Call the Counter
Home of Julia's Pepperoni Rolls — warm, old-school WV rolls with your pick of provolone or spicy hot pepper cheese, from a bakery the regulars are fiercely loyal to. The only prices the owner publishes are bulk: their online store sells cases at $59.95 — 24 large or 36 small rolls, which works out to roughly $1.67–2.50 a roll. No single-roll walk-in price is posted anywhere, so call (304) 292-5480 for counter prices before a special trip.
📍 1644 Blue Horizon Dr · ⏳ Call ahead — (304) 292-5480
🍎
Apple Annie's
Scratch Comfort Food & Pastries 💡 Call for Prices
A go-to for scratch-made comfort food and a heavenly bakery case of cookies, pies and — of course — pepperoni rolls, served on beloved WV-made Fiestaware. Regulars swear by the breakfast burrito, and daily dinner specials run to fried pork chops and chicken parm. Their website blocks price checks behind a bot wall, so we can't verify the ticket — call (304) 322-2859 for current prices. Open Mon–Fri 7am–9pm and Sat 8am–9pm at Pierpont Landings; closed Sunday.
📍 6120 Mid Atlantic Dr (Pierpont Landings) · ⏳ Mon–Fri 7–9, Sat 8–9, closed Sun
🍺
Mountain State Brewing Co.
Happy Hour 4–6pm — $1 Off Drafts, Half-Price Apps
A family-owned West Virginia brewpub with downtown and Star City taprooms, always packed on game days. The house beers include two of the state's best sellers — Almost Heaven Amber Ale and Miner's Daughter Stout — and the wood-fired pizzas are made for splitting. Straight talk on price: their own site publishes no food menu with numbers, so we can't do the pie math for you. What is owner-confirmed is the happy hour — 4 to 6pm, $1 off drafts and half-price apps — which is the cheapest way in the door. (304) 241-1976.
📍 54 Clay St (Downtown) + Star City · ⏳ Happy hour 4–6pm · call for hours
🌮
✓ verified
Los Mariachis
Two Lunch Specials — $15.98 💡 Mon–Sat Before 2:30 Only
The lively student-and-professor favorite for sizzling fajitas and margarita towers — but the under-$20 window is lunch. Per the menu posted on their own site, lunch specials start at $7.99, so two people eat for about $16, Mon–Sat 11am–2:30pm. At dinner the math flips: the cheapest combos are $13.99 each, $27.98 for two — over the line, and the "$14 for two" our old card claimed was never achievable. Three Morgantown locations, outdoor seating, reliably packed.
📍 3 locations incl. Pierpont · ⏳ Lunch deal Mon–Sat 11–2:30
🌯
✓ verified
Black Bear Burritos
Two Build-Your-Own Burritos — $11.58 💡 Two Favorites $18.28
A true Morgantown institution, with live music many nights. Owner menu: build-your-own burritos start at $5.79, so two are $11.58 — and the named favorites work too: the Irie Member (Creole-inspired, homemade Jamaican jerk sauce) is $10.99 and the pesto quesadilla $7.29, so $18.28 covers both. The downtown Pleasant Street shop has closed; the Evansdale one at 3119 University Ave carries on. Note the hours: Mon–Sat 11am–10pm, closed Sunday.
📍 3119 University Ave (Evansdale) · ⏳ Mon–Sat 11am–10pm, closed Sun
☕
✓ verified
Terra Cafe
Pepperoni Roll + Soup & Salad — $13.00 💡 Daytime Only — Closes 3pm
Part coffee shop, part scratch eatery, with a pet-friendly patio and artful pastry cases. Their own lunch menu does the budget work: a pepperoni roll is $5 and the soup-and-salad is $8, so two people share a spread for $13.00 — or add the $10 pepperoni roll & mac and call it $18. Steer clear of the full sandwiches, honest caveat: they run $14–19 each, so two break $28. The bigger catch is the clock — Terra is daytime only and closes at 3pm, every day.
📍 425 Industrial Ave · ⏳ Mon–Fri 8–3, Sat–Sun 9–3
🍚
Yama
Japanese Rice Bowls 💡 Cash Only — Call Ahead
The student-favorite counter for great-value Japanese rice bowls — pick your meat or vegetables — plus sushi and other plates. Yama publishes no menu anywhere we can check, so call ahead for current prices. The real trick is the schedule, tighter than any list admits: dinner only Tue–Wed 5:30–8:30pm, lunch only Thu–Fri 11:30am–2:30pm, closed Saturday through Monday. Bring cash — cards aren't taken.
📍 387½ High St · ⏳ Tue–Wed 5:30–8:30pm · Thu–Fri 11:30–2:30 · cash only
💡 Pro tip: Morgantown's budget window is the clock, not the menu. Terra Cafe closes at 3pm sharp, Los Mariachis' $7.99 lunch specials end at 2:30, and Yama keeps hours so tight (two dinner nights, two lunch days, cash only) that a call ahead saves a wasted trip. On the other end, Casa D'Amici runs to 2:30–3:30am late in the week, and Mid Atlantic Market opens at 5:30am daily. Mountain State's 4–6pm happy hour ($1 off drafts, half-price apps) is the cheapest brewpub seat in town. If a price has moved, flag it on our main directory so we can update it.
We checked all fifteen of this page's cards against owner menus on August 14, 2026. Two didn't survive the math, and they're listed here with the numbers rather than quietly deleted:
Bigger than one storefront, smaller than the home-page national list — regional chains with real Morgantown addresses.
🌭
Sheetz
Meal Bundlez from $9.77+ 💡 Confirm in the App
The Altoona, PA-born 24/7 made-to-order kitchen, with 1012 University Ave sitting in WVU's front yard. At our last successful read of the chain's own ordering menu, the Meal Bundlez board did the two-person math: Hot Doggie Delight $19.16+ (six hot dogs, two Extra Biggz appz, two drinks), Tailgate for 2 $19.55+, and solo bundles like Flatz & Snacks from $9.77+. The ordering site blocked our August 14, 2026 re-check, so treat those as starting points and confirm in the app. One presence note other lists miss: the fuel-free University Place store at 2151 University Ave is reported closed, so don't count on it.
📍 1012 University Ave + other Morgantown stores · ⏳ 24/7 · Meal Bundlez on the MTO menu
These chain deals work anywhere in the country, including Morgantown.
🚒
Firehouse Subs
$5 Snackers Format 💡 Prices Vary by Store — Check the App
Founded in 1994 by two firefighter brothers, now 1,200+ stores — one in town at 1108 Giant Street. A correction to ourselves: our old card quoted prices from a Jacksonville, Florida store on a Morgantown page. The chain's ordering system won't show us a readable Morgantown menu, so we won't print numbers we can't tie to this store — the $5 Firehouse Snackers half-subs (BLT, Cordon Bleu, Sweet & Spicy Ham, Turkey Jalapeño) are the budget format when your store runs them, but price the Giant Street store in the app or call (304) 212-4106 first.
📍 1108 Giant St · ⏳ Check the app for store prices
🧀
✓ verified
Buffalo Wild Wings
$17.99 Wing Deal — 20 Boneless + Fries + 4 Dips 💡 Online/App Only
The live deal on the chain's own site as of August 14, 2026: the $17.99 Wing Deal — 20 boneless wings, a large fries and four dips, easily dinner for two under the line — for online and app orders only. The Pick 6 our old card called "a reliable two-for-$20 play at any BWW" isn't currently promoted; it's a rotating seasonal offer, and when it runs, 8 of its 12 entrée choices cost extra. Promos rotate, so check the app before you order. Two Morgantown stores, both by the malls.
📍 8735 University Town Center Dr + 1099 Suncrest Towne Centre Dr · ⏳ Promos rotate
🍝
Olive Garden
Lunch-Sized Favorites — Mon–Fri Before 3pm 💡 From Around $9, Varies
Branding update most lists missed: the weekday lunch program is now called Lunch-Sized Favorites — the "Lunch Duos" name our old card used is retired. It still runs Mon–Fri before 3pm on the chain's own specials page, with lunch-sized entrées plus unlimited soup or salad and breadsticks. Olive Garden doesn't publish Morgantown prices we can read; lunch entrées have historically started around $9, which puts two lunches around $18 and up — borderline, so check the store menu. The $6 Take Home Entrée added to a dine-in order is the other owner-listed lever.
📍 1000 University Town Centre Dr · ⏳ Mon–Fri before 3pm